I just saw our AA West Tenn team play
And overall I wasn't very impressed. I went to their game against the Tennessee Smokies (Knoxville). Here are some thoughts about what I saw.
Bobbie Brownlie isn't very good. He only touched 88 mphs on the gun, and I only saw that once. He mostly stayed around 85-86 mph and was hitable. Not a lot of movement either, although he did get hit near his left hand/wrist in his first at-bat. I don't think that affected him too much though, he didn't look good from the start. I can't see him in the majors anytime soon.
Eric Patterson looked good. Good arm, pretty good defense. He hit a nice double and he probably could have taken 3rd on the throw home but wisely held up. The best part is, he didn't swing at everything thrown. In fact I think the scouting report was to throw it up around his eyes as he saw what seemed like more than a few pitches up there, but he didn't swing and miss like his brother would. Overall he was impressive.
Nick Jackson and Brandon Sing look like airport team guys. They look good on the field but didn't produce much. They both took walks but otherwise swung and missed a lot. Jackson looked better than Sing, he made a few descent plays in RF.
Brian Dopirak reminded me a lot of Dante Bichette, simillar body type. I don't see him having a Bichette type career though, at best he looks like an Eric Hinske waiting to happen, without the one good season rookie of the year. Maybe he's still getting his baseball legs back? He didn't start the game but went in to play first after Miguel Negron fouled a ball off his leg and was taken out.
Paul Schappert looked okay, think Will Ohman here, left hander out of the pen. He looks like he could be a LOOGY in the big leagues, descent velocity and some late movement but probably wouldn't make it through the order twice without running in to problems. Carmen Pignatiello looked okay too but at least in this game Schappert was a little more impressive.
Tony Richie just wasn't very good, slow bat, he was late on everything including 73 mph curveballs. He had a few at-bats where he went deep into the count and he also took a walk but I just don't see him being able to hit enough to be anything more than a backup in the majors, and I don't think he'll ever get there.
Gary Cates is a little guy who reminded me of a Chone Figgins/David Eckstein high energy type guy. Sort of a weak arm, he would probably be better off at second instead of short, but not while Patterson is on the team. He hit a ball to the warning track and it looked like that's about as hard as he could hit it. He takes a good hard swing but just doesn't have enough oomph. If he makes it to the majors he looks like he'd be an Auggie Ojeda type player.
Overall, not too impressive. They were no-hit for the first four innings and I was starting to wonder. It was just one game though, I'd like to get to see them some more. There were some scouts in the crowd, I don't know for who though. Maybe something is in the works but I'd guess they were scouting the Diamondbacks players since their parent club is more likely to be in the market near the deadline.
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of SB Nation or Al Yellon, managing editor (unless it's a FanPost posted by Al). FanPost opinions are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable baseball fans.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Nice post!
On Patterson, is there any chance he could be called up later this year? I've heard on here that Pie isn't ready for MLB, so I would assume that Patterson probably isn't ready either. But who knows?
And on Richie, wasn't he was supposed to be the next Rick Wilkins? I remember that when he was 16 he was rated the best baseball player in the country for his age, but it seems his development has slowed.
Lastly, could any of these guys be packaged with guys who will likely be dealt before the deadline? I guess im trying to ask if there are any farmhands they have given up on or have a surplus number of at a certain position.
Patterson
Not sure about Richie, he looked good behind the plate but Brownlie got tagged so maybe he didn't call a good game? He didn't look good at the plate though, and I didn't see anything that would lead me to believe he's going to make it to the majors. I'm not a scout though so who knows......
If Brownlie has any name value left it would probably be a good idea to go ahead and deal him. We've got plenty of pitchers in the minors who are ahead of him and if his velocity isn't any better than what I saw I don't see how he can get by in the majors.
Otherwise, Jackson and Sing probably have some prospect value as far as trades go, and Dopirak certainly does. Of those three I think I'd like to keep Jackson the most but Dopirak may end up being better. Jackson looked like more of a complete player though and looked more like a minor league stud, a la David Kelton. Again, I'm not a scout so what do I know.
No one else looked as though they had mastered AA yet besides maybe Patterson, so if we move anyone I saw besides him I wouldn't be too upset. In fact I kinda think Brownlie should be dealt if he's worth anything.
Overrating "prospects"...
And Jackson, though hitting better this year, is going to be twenty-seven in September.
The time to trade both of these guys was two years ago. They are worthless as "prospects".
I didn't check their age
Farm system
by Mike63 on Jun 26, 2006 2:38 PM CDT reply actions
I'll catch the West Tenn boys again
It'll be good to see Gallagher, Fox and Campusano for the first time, as well as see if there's any noticeable difference in Patterson's plate approach (he had some good gap contact last time I saw him).
Moore and Dopirak's defense looked good in the last games I saw them in, but their plate appearances were average for the league. Greenburg's gone now, so I'll see a new outfielder (perhaps Miguel Negron?). Nic Jackson's also fun to watch, but he's not getting any younger and I have my doubts that he'll move on.

by 




















