Movie Review: "The Great Debaters"
Tired of reading about steroids and the Mitchell Report?
Yeah, me too.
So while we wait for the expected announcement later today of the Kosuke Fukudome press conference, I wanted to tell you about "The Great Debaters", which will be released to theaters on Christmas Day. I had the opportunity to see a DGA sponsored screening a couple of nights ago.
The movie, based on real events, stars and is also directed by Denzel Washington, who plays a professor and debating coach at Wiley College, a black college located in Marshall, Texas, a small town not far from Shreveport. The year is 1935, and it's the Jim Crow South -- we see events that both define some of the political movements of the day (Washington's character, Mel Tolson, gets involved in union organizing), and we are constantly reminded that the "Negro" (that term is just beginning to replace the somewhat pejorative "colored" as the "correct" term of the times to refer to black people) is put in what white people feel is his "place".
Tolson holds tryouts for the debate team, and winnows the students down to four -- one of whom is someone who's clearly had a troubled past, one who can't stomach Tolson's political views and quits the team, a female student, and the fourth, whose character is only sixteen in the film, Denzel Whitaker, a 17-year-old actor who looks fourteen. The young Whitaker plays this young debater with great dignity and class; in the film his father, a doctor played also with the same quiet dignity by Forest Whitaker (who, despite a resemblance to Denzel Whitaker, is NOT his real-life father), both keeps him in line as a father would have in the 1930's, and also strongly encourages his education, in a belief that education can actually help him rise up out of the situation he was born into.
Tolson hones the debaters' skills and they begin to win debates against similar black colleges. When they try to arrange matches against other schools, they meet with the subtle racism of the time. At last, Oklahoma City University agrees to debate them, the first white college to do so, and while the debate is going on, half the white audience walks out.
The characters are well-drawn and speak realistic dialogue that doesn't sound like "movie dialogue". The climax of the film comes when Harvard University, whose national championship debate team has heard about Wiley's debate winning streak, invites them to come to Boston to debate them. No spoilers here -- go see this film, which has terrific performances as always by two of the best actors of our time, Washington and Forest Whitaker, and keep your eyes on Denzel Whitaker, who nearly steals the whole show from his elder counterparts. There will be Oscar buzz about this film, and justifiably so -- one of the best of the year.
AYRating: 
0 recs |
10 comments
Comments
Waddle & Silvy
by manny k on Dec 19, 2007 10:20 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
Confirmed.
by Al on Dec 19, 2007 10:31 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
cubs.com
by manny k on Dec 19, 2007 10:45 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
No interest in THE GREAT DEBATERS
pleasing films that are not my kind of film but the real reason
I won't see it is that it plays with facts for no good reason.
I don't know the "true" story very well but what I DO know is
that the opponent was NOT Harvard bu USC. Apparently USC is not good or audience pleasing enough , they have to make it a
more "recognizable" University. Hey if someone does a film about the 69 Mets I think they should change their World Series opponent to the Yankees. I mean that would be much more dramatic. I am just sick and tired of "inspired by ( no more
"based on") a true story films that think nothing of changing major facts to fit what they think is easier or more popular to
make.
by jessica on Dec 19, 2007 12:48 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
I agree, Jessica
The movie Disney made about Texas Western basketball team winning the NCAA championship or Remember The Titans come to mind. Unless you're a complete racist you've got to want the teams to win but there's such a laziness and sameness in the storytelling that if the cast wasn't good, they'd be laughable parodies of themselves.
Don't plan on seeing the big debate picture but I did see Atonement which Al reviewed a few days back. Just the kind of movie Hollywood and the Academy have wet dreams over - not complete fluff but not nearly as important as it pretends to be either. Very much of the The English Patient - art film for the multi-plex school of movie making.
Juno was good, though. The dialogue was way too precious but the cast is great and they pull it off. By the end the film is downright moving.
And Al - Go see Much Ado About Nothing and tell me Denzel is one of the best actors of our time. He's alright and he's been pretty good as a bad guy in a couple of movies - Training Day comes to mind - but his acting range is the equivalent of Ron Cey's range at third. See how I brought it back to baseball?
by TR on Dec 19, 2007 9:39 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
You're a member of the WGA, right?
I don't have a problem with films being "inspired" by real events. I fully understand that they're not intended to be a literal reconstruction of what happened.
Remember, feature films are, for the most part, intended to entertain. If I want to know exactly what happened with Wiley College's debaters, I'm sure there are books out there about the topic, and if anyone wanted to make a film about what actually happened, they could make a documentary. "The Great Debaters" isn't a documentary and wasn't intended to be.
by Al on Dec 20, 2007 9:07 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
I understand, Al.
by TR on Dec 20, 2007 1:17 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
In some ways, I agree with you.
by Al on Dec 20, 2007 3:54 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
I wanted to see it...
I went to see I Am Legend. I never watch scary movies, and that was the scariest movie I've ever seen. I wasn't horror-scary obviously, but it made jump so much I jumped at everything I saw in corners afterwards.
by sparkles721 on Dec 19, 2007 11:24 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
movie lovers, check this out...
Chicagoans can catch it on WBEZ and everyone can subscribe to the podcast on iTunes. Or just listen online!
by EliasTirade on Dec 20, 2007 9:21 AM CST reply actions 0 recs

by 


















