Idiot Cub Fans Infuriate Me
A look at a disease taking its toll on cubdom.
Ok gang, its time to take a look in the mirror at ourselves and figure out what kind of fans we want to be. I see two ways, the kind of fans who know what they are talking about because the took the time to educate themselves, and the knee-jerk reactionaries who spout off with nonsense. Cubdom has always been split nearly along these lines, you have the fratastic antics of the beer boys of summer who could care less about the actual game but just want to appear shirtless on WGN with some part of "Cubbies" or "Believe" painted on their chest, and then you have the fans who keep a pay attention or keep a scorecard or run/participate in a blog and DISCUSS the team on a level above watching 6 games on TV or using bubble gum cards for their statistical intake. And let me say, I for one am getting very tired of the first group of fans.
Thanks to computers and the internet becoming affordable to all we have seen a rise in those "fans" posting both at BCB and other places . The arguments are all the same, scrappy players like Theriot and Fontenot and Murton are the elixir needed for a WS trophy while more talented yet somehow less pleasing players like Soriano, Ramirez and Pie get toasted for being lazy, un clutch-y, toosly, not white eeerr intangible enough to win. Fans who take the time to know what they talk about see their best efforts at honest dialogue go to waste as the ignorant fan will either ignore the truth presented to them and never respond directly, or say that the rest of us dont know "jack scratch" about how real baseball goes down and keep on writing dribble.
For the majority of fans this type of debate is something to pass over, its not a big deal in the big scheme of things but permit me to throw this idea (borrowed in part, dear reader) out there. The type of fanship I have discussed above is not only infuriating to deal with but is also bad for all Cub fans. Having a large section of your fanbase clamoring for players who they feel "play the game the right way" or whatever it is that Theriot and Murton do exactly, while savaging the actual talent which provides pennants is detrimental because it creates a fanbase which can be pacified with a mediocre team. Whoever owns the Cubs could field a team of scrappers and grinders that would lead us to 80 wins every year, but I suppose if they got their bunt singles and played small ball well enough the aforementioned fans would be happy.
Watching the fans at Wrigley boo both hero Kerry Wood and the team as whole today in the 6th gives me hope that the spark which was awakened in all of us in 2003 still burns. That we as a whole will not be content with being labeled "the happiest/best fans in baseball" while our team screws up on the field. We should all be vocal in demanding that we are provided with the talent to win year in and year out. Not because we haven’t won for 100 years or any of that hyperbole, but because every year all of us contribute our hard earned $ to the team. We make the Cubs profitable and therefore we should be provided with an entire roster of players as good as Soriano, Ramirez, Lee ect ect and almost devoid of replacement level table filler like Theriot. Settling or asking for anything less than this is being a poor fan, if you will watch a shitty club lose, then ownership will almost certainly provide you with one. The boo's and trash on the field of 2006 must have played some part in the Tribune's decision to finally open the wallet and provide us with actual players and that’s a lesson none of us should forget in the future.
So what is the cure for this disease of overbearing, vacant minded know-nothings? I would suggest ignoring the repeat offenders all together (Al is much much more tolerant of certain posters than I am which is probably why he and his blog are so popular) attempt to educate those who make some dubious judgments out of inexperience. My first posts here at BCB way back in 2006 are a prime example of this, I had always been a casual fan and my first attempts at dialogue are pretty painful to read. The more knowledgeable posters here at the time savaged me and although it was hard to accept that maybe I didnt know a damn thing I was talking about, I got over the hurt feelings and started to look up things myself. Hopefully, anyone who took the time to read this realizes Im not advocating forced readings of Sabermetrics or anything like that, CCD who helped run a former cubs blog isnt a stat man by any means but provided good non statistical insight into the game as do many others. For those who want to learn more with stats there are so many good ones out there as well as posters here like Josh and Cwyers.
So lets not let the mob take over here or in our fan base overall unless you want to see the 2010 Cubs feature Darin Erstad in the OF and David Eckstein at SS : )
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of SB Nation or Al Yellon, managing editor (unless it's a FanPost posted by Al). FanPost opinions are valued expressions of opinion by passionate and knowledgeable baseball fans.
2 recs |
37 comments
|
Comments
Hear Hear
I'd like to ask Dylan here if he'd like to be my best friend. However, there's no way you're ever, ever going to get rid of the yuppie/frat boy/reactionary crowd, and it's as simple as the ballpark's location. It still is the world's biggest beer garden, and unfortunately, always will be. This leads to mucho, mucho idiocy. Once people enjoy drinking there, and do it regularly, they think they're fans.
This is a different category than the other side of idiot Cub fans, which would be the the buses from Iowa contingent, the nostalgia crowd, who don't want Wrigley changed in anyway, despite the added revenue that would only help the team. Because of the long standing association with WGN, and the folklore of the Cubs that has spiraled out of control, you'll never get rid of these people either.
There are some of us, sir. Just have to wade through a whole sea of crap to find those ports.
Iowa fans
I grew up in Chicago, but have lived in Iowa for over thirty years. I'm not sure where you acquired your keen insight into the minds of Iowa Cubs fans, but I can assure you that worrying about changes to Wrigley Field is of little or no concern to the vast majority of people who take bus trips to games. If anything, most probably fall into the beer drinking, party at the ballpark category of idiots, but in that regard they're hardly alone. I'm sure there are one or two who think Wrigley Field should have been left exactly the way it was when it was Weegham Park, but you could probably find just as many or more Chicagoans who feel the same way. If you want to criticize Iowa fans, feel free to do so when they deserve it, but don't slander them all based on anecdotal or imaginary evidence.
by Mike Vails Evil Twin on Apr 3, 2008 10:08 AM CDT up reply actions
I see what
you're talking about. However, I'm pretty positive every team has the fans that you mention. I personally don't don't mind seeing people who want to give players that we may not agree with a shot. I think its important to note that there are obviously different levels of fans, like young posters, and people who are just casual fans, and I don't think you can try and push those people out. Really, if someone says something that isn't that bright, it shouldn't be that hard to just pass it by. I wish we could come on here and have the most knowledgable posts in the world, unfortunately, you won't find that anywhere.
As for the Iowa contingent, I'm from Dubuque, I know the bus scene, it ain't that cool. I refuse to take a bus ride. But not all Iowa fans are like that. I'm sure every other surrounding state has the same thing.
Its funny, you spend most of your life gripping a baseball. And in the end, its almost always the other way around.
Could you please clarify
what you meant with this statement:
not white eeerr intangible enough to win
I think I have an idea of what you're getting at, but I'm not 100% sure and would rather have you spell it out than me assume and misinterpret. Thanks.
Moving on, I share your disappointment with the crowds. It made me embarrassed today to see many, many people act like complete idiots -- especially people my age.
There's nothing we can do about anyone else's behavior. People will only change if they want to change. All we can do is hope to lead by example.
One of my favorite sayings is "You can't take the sky from me." [It's a couplet from the theme song to the (amazing) TV show Firefly.] The masses may act like idiots, but we can't and won't let them ruin our team and our game.
"These are the saddest of possible words: Tinker to Evers to Chance."
Fire Joe Morgan
is a good place to start for information, presented in a very entertaining manner. Just search the site for "Ryan Theriot", "Darin Erstad", and "David Eckstein" and you'll have PLENTY of reading material...
It helps explain why a guy like Theriot may indeed have value and be a good player to have on your club, but as a role player at best. NOT a starter. And certainly not a leadoff hitter. I love The Riot, but let's be honest about his strengths...and his weaknesses.
For those unfamiliar, FJM parses the work of sports journalists in an amusing, but factually-based, fashion. Frequent targets: Gordon Wittenmyer, Joe Morgan (duh), Tim McCarver (duh), virtually all of MSNBC.com, Bill Plaschke, etc.
(As with all my posts, links will open in a new window.)
One caveat for FJM:
Occasional profane language warning
Alan Trammell: Assistant (to the) Manager
KillFiles
Maybe Al can request that the powers that be create something akin to killfiles where you can ignore the postings of certain members. If someone is stupid or obnoxious on Usenet, I just plonk them and then I only have to read their trash when someone quotes it replying back to them.
Agreed 100%
It's not just on the Cubs site either...it's everywhere. I'm a 25 year old male who played college baseball, and I have no children. I coached youth baseball last year with a guy who's only knowledge came from the 6 games a year he watched. It's frustrating, but it's a fact of life...people want to give their opinions just to be heard.
I think you'd have less angst
if you redefined the word "fan" for yourself.
Fan is short for fanatic. Showing up at a game does not constitute a fan. Personally I call them attendees. If you separate the fans from attendees, you'll realize the difference is night and day. The worst example of that is a Bulls game; talk about sheeple. If the scoreboard ever blew a fuse, you would be able to hear a pin drop.
Don't worry, that "attendee" infection has spread all over the country in all sports. You can't kill that infection so it's best to try to ignore it and know you're above it. The only requirement to get into a game is money, not knowledge. Hell, I had some ass-clown ask me (in the bleachers none-the-less) what 4-6-3 meant. Talk about being annointed one of Dogbert's in-DUH-viduals instantly.
Knee jerk reactions from ass-clowns like that really doesn't matter, does it? Now I'm not saying drink the Cubbie koolaid while looking through the Cubbie blue sunglasses (we have those here too) but once you realize there's a lot of dumb-asses out there you'll be able to separate yourself from that.
Well said.
n/t
"I've always felt that starting pitching is the most important part of the rotation." - Joe Morgan, Sunday Night Baseball 8-12-07
Dylan...
... you and I have not always seen eye-to-eye. This time, I happen to agree with you. The angst spilled in the last two days over TWO LOSSES (one of which came close to being a dramatic win) is unbelievable.
I do wish you hadn't used the word "idiot" in your title, but otherwise, you're spot on.
"That's my opinion and if you don't like it, well, I have others." ~ Groucho Marx
Booing
Watching the fans at Wrigley boo both hero Kerry Wood and the team as whole today in the 6th gives me hope that the spark which was awakened in all of us in 2003 still burns.Really?
It gave me heartburn.
It was terrible to see. One game in, and already we're booing one of the most talented players on the club, not to mention the longest-tenured Cub, and why? Because he had a bad outing.
If this team wins 100 games, it means they lost 62. Should, then, we be sure to boo the Cubs every time they lose? Every time they disappoint us? Of course not, losing is part of the game.
I'm embarrassed for Cubs fans when they boo their own team. It's the sign of an infantile fan base, not a hungry one.
Booing is an acceptable reaction in certain situations.
Monday wasn't one of them. Players fail at times. It happens. We always root for the OTHER team to fail, right?
Booing failure of the kind that happened Monday is unacceptable. Booing when players are clearly not giving EFFORT, I think, is more acceptable.
The Cubs didn't lose the last two games because of a lack of effort. Of that I am certain.
"That's my opinion and if you don't like it, well, I have others." ~ Groucho Marx
Booing when Ohman would walk the bases load and leave the mess for Wuertz....now thats acceptable ahha
Poor Matty Murton....
by Keystone80435 on Apr 3, 2008 11:04 AM CDT up reply actions
Oh bullshit
booing is part of any game. There's nothing wrong with that. Saying the team is finished after 2 of 162 games, there's all that's wrong with that.
There was some dirtbag in the LF bleachers a couple years ago holding up a sign that said real fans don't boo. He's lucky he didn't get thrown over the fence onto the sidewalk adjacent to Waveland Ave. I'd like to see his sorry ass in Philly, or Queens, or Beantown or the Bronx.
Booing a bad call or booing a player for bad output is to be expected. Physical errors are to be expected, mental ones have to be corrected and quickly. Booing a physical error, well that's a bit overboard, booing a mental error should be expected. What happened to Jacques Jones the past couple years, now that is not to be expected, nor tolerated. If he screwed up a play, fine, but the other shit, that shall neither be condoned nor accepted in any way.
And Kerry Wood is a hero? Why, because he felt guilty in practically stealing $32M between 04-06 inclusive so he re-signed for "a lower base salary with incentives"? Because he's the longest tenured player? Because he could go to FA and get more money? Hero's are the people who defend our freedom, our sovereignty, our flag, so we can go to the ballpark and express our feelings openly.
This isn't the ol' lovable losers that is so equated to the Cubbies of decades past. October 14 & 15, 2003 changed that...forever.
I'm so tired of this attempt at sensorship, like the entire 41,230 at the park has to look through the Cubbie Blue sunglasses, while drinking the koolaid. There's a higher level of expectation and with that comes angst and frustration when those expectations are not being met; even for a day. When a team is not expected to win, losing doesn't hurt as much as when a team IS expected to win.
I agree
I like Kerry, and hope for all our sakes that he has a great season. However, he seems to get a free pass. People boo. It's a fact of life. Pro athletes that can't handle it and complain should take their multi-millions and go home. Play hard, try your best, fans will back you. Start the season in a daze AGAIN after having to recover last year, people get pissed.
I'm not as bitter and angry as people like lemon20pie and MDBNIU, but I'm no Polyanna, either. We all want this team to win. And with this much talent and payroll, we expect certain things that we are yet to see...2 games in.
Today isn't exactly a pivotal game, but a win would be nice. I have a terrible feeling that by the 4th inning Dempster will be long gone and people will be clamouring for Jon Lieber in the rotation.
It was the offense that held this team back at the beginning of last year, and hopefully we don't see a replay of the first two months!
Soriano should hit 5th. Period.
by Canadian Cubs Fan on Apr 3, 2008 9:06 AM CDT up reply actions
High expectations = Boo every time the team gets scored on?
There's a higher level of expectation and with that comes angst and frustration when those expectations are not being met; even for a day. When a team is not expected to win, losing doesn't hurt as much as when a team IS expected to win.Sure, all that's to be expected, but adults don't express themselves by throwing a temper tantrum when things don't go their way, and booing because you're unhappy that a game isn't going the way you want it to is just that.
And, believe it or not, booing is not just expressing unhappiness. It is an indictment of the players, especially when it's directed at a particular one, as was the case on Monday when fans booed Kerry Wood. It's the fans' way of saying, "you didn't perform the way I wanted you to, so f*** you." It's childish. It expresses an expectation for instant, and constant, gratification.
Beyond that, booing your own team like that displays a startling lack of understanding of baseball. It's totally unreasonable to expect every single game to go your way, much less every single play. So, what, now we boo our own players when they don't get a base hit in a critical situation? It happens. Baseball players don't have magic powers, folks. A player who gets a base hit one third of the time with a man on base is performing above the average, yet, apparently, he's going to get booed more than he's going to get cheered if this crap continues.
I'll commend Cubs crowds for something: when they are excited, the roar is deafening. Over the last five years, i've been to plenty of midseason games where, at a critical juncture, you're getting a level of intensity from the crowd that would only be seen in the playoffs at any other ballpark, if at all. I went to all three games against Milwaukee last August, and I can't remember ever going to a game where the tension inside the ballpark was as high as it was on those three nights, and that includes the three playoff games I've gone to since 2003 -- and that's a credit to the fans.
However, that doesn't give them some kind of moral authority to turn around and boo every time they're disappointed.
So, yes, in my estimation, there is something wrong with booing your own club.
This is the major leagues
not your kids' league. There's a huge difference.
All I'll say is you keep getting hyped up about the booing and keep trying to stop it, I'll roll with the punches and not let it bother me and we'll see who's more upset in the end.
Actually I'm not that big into booing
but I sure as hell won't stop anyone who does boo within reason.
There are Cub fans and there are sheep/lemmings
IMO
"Hey.....Cubs win!!!" ---Harry
"Swung on belted!!!"---Chip
Disagree
I've got a few disagreements with your main idea--that the Cubs "fans" who go to the game to drink themselves silly and those that like players such as Murton, Theriot and Fontenot are the same. In my opinion, those are two groups--one who's opinions can be safely ignored and one who's opinions, if presented intelligently, should at least be heard.
We know the drunkards don't really care about the team construction, chemistry, hustle, OBP, advanced defensive metrics, etc. They care about the beer and being out in the sun. As long as they don't ruin my enjoyment of the game (which they sometimes do), I could care less if they're at the park or not.
Lumping the second group of fans--fans who support players who "hustle", have "intangibles", etc---in with the drunkards does a disservice to our baseball debate. As the last few World Series winners have proven, there's more than one way to build a Championship team. To say that people who disagree with your way to build the team are all "know-nothings" seems to be grouping too many disparate groups together.
Anyway, that's my 11 cents.
"Don't think; it can only hurt the ball club."
You mention World Series winners
The Boston Red Sox - one of the biggest differences between the two teams is that damn near every hitter in the Sox lineup knows how to work a count - make the pitcher throw strikes, get in favorable counts, then pound mistakes. Aside from Fuke, DeRo, and DLee, no one else really works counts. I guess ARam does sometimes, but not consistantly.
I thought when Gerald Perry came on board, a guy that preaches plate discipline and high OBP, things would change...
Soriano should hit 5th. Period.
by Canadian Cubs Fan on Apr 3, 2008 10:19 AM CDT up reply actions
they've been getting better
really, they have. Theriot was 2 for 4 yesterday, and he worked the count. Pie has walked several times -- and also, natch, looked at a few called third strikes. Soto's homerun was on a worked count. Ramirez walked. Even Soriano wasn't swinging on the first pitch.
2008: The year we put it all together.
by drewishdrewid on Apr 3, 2008 10:30 AM CDT up reply actions
Other World Series Winners
I haven't gone back and checked the stats, but I seem to remember the 2002 Angels not being known as a patient team. They had good contact hitters and an amazing bullpen. The 2001 Diamondbacks won because they had two pitchers who pitched great when it counted, and the 2005 White Sox had great pitching when it counted. The 2003 Marlins...well, I can't talk about it.
On the other side, the A's have had teams that are built around plate discipline and high OBP and haven't won a World Series recently (well, more recently than we have :( And the Twins, who are built completely differently from the A's have been in the playoffs nearly as often.
Anyway, all I'm saying is there's more than one way to skin a cat.
"Don't think; it can only hurt the ball club."
Very true
I just like the idea of making pitchers work, forcing higher pitch counts and getting into other teams 'pens early. I still believe our bullpen will be a strength. I am worried about Howry over the next month or two...
Soriano should hit 5th. Period.
by Canadian Cubs Fan on Apr 3, 2008 10:49 AM CDT up reply actions
As do I
I like players who work the count, have a high OBP, have an amazing set of physical skills, etc.
I also like scrappy players.
I have issues.
"Don't think; it can only hurt the ball club."
I think the point is
to paraphrase Marilyn Monroe: Having patient hitters isn't everything. But, my goodness, doesn't it help?
dead on!!
dylan you could not have hit it even more dead on than that! and thank you! I am also sick of these fake cub fans! I am, like most cubs fans displeased how they have started the season but i am not saying that our allstar players are worthless like these yahoos are! i also think fans need to realize that we are playing the brewers a very good team and debatably cubs #1 brewers #2 or vice versia in the talent wise of the division.
I find it ironic
the next FanPost right above you. Case in point.
"Prince Fielder Dies Of Inside-The-Park Homerun" - The Onion
Who cares
Why should you complain about other pople being obnoxious? they pay money to watch the game just like you, and just because they are drinking and have their chests painted doesnt mean they are not intellient cub fans.
I for one am sick of people like you, complaining about what other people are doing.
deal with it buddy
Put your shirt back on and the beer down
AND BACK AWAY FROM THE COMPUTER
"Hey.....Cubs win!!!" ---Harry
"Swung on belted!!!"---Chip
well
its stupid people constantly complain what other people do at the stadium. Grow up and focus on your self.
If you focus on yourself and not others opinions
You wouldnt be responding to this. BTW< I agree with you.
"Hey.....Cubs win!!!" ---Harry
"Swung on belted!!!"---Chip
On opening day
some fellow "fan" as he called himself as ked me if it was Kyle Farnsworth pitching the 10th.
That my friends, is a true Cub fan!
Calm down.

by 




















