I have a lot of respect for Bob Sacramento’s work, and I’d be the first to say that he knows far more than I ever would. As I always note, I’m just a fan.

But did Bob Sacramento plagiarize me? First off, I could care less. I’m just surprised.

Bob’s Comment on Caridad:

Caridad was one of the Cubs’ few international signings from 2007, coming over from Japan as a 24 year old. Esmailan has very deceptive secondary pitches, a curve and change, which both grade as plus pitches. He often uses his 88-91 mph fastball to setup his secondary stuff that he seems more comfortable with throwing. Caridad, like Atkins is a gamer, he has no problem challenging hitters or throwing them inside. Esmailan is also a very intelligent pitcher who works his spotsHe’s a hot name making the rounds this offseason, particularly with suggestions that he’ll start in AAA from Fleita. I like him. He throws strikes. I don’t know if his stuff is good enough to be anything more than a back of the rotation type, though, and as such Atkins, for his better year and being at a higher level, gets the edge over him. Solid winter so far and if he can maintain the higher velo, then the equation changes

Compare the bold aspect to this post I made over on MiLB when Sickels Top 20 list came out (November):

http://www.minorleagueball.com/2008/11/29/675375/chicago-cubs-top-20-prospe

12. Esmailin Caridad, C+. He’s a hot name making the rounds this offseason, particularly with suggestions that he’ll start in AAA from Fleita. I like him. He throws strikes. I don’t know if his stuff is good enough to be anything more than a back of the rotation type, though, and as such Atkins, for his better year and being at a higher level, gets the edge over him. Solid winter so far and if he can maintain the higher velo, then the equation changes.

What’s he doing putting together Top 10 Cubbie lists? Perhaps he did indeed simply cut and paste.

Bob Saccamano is Cosmo’s golfing buddy.