Well, this one ought to be interesting.
Yes, I admit it. Carlos Silva was a really bad pitcher in 2008. In 2009, he pitched badly in only eight games (six starts) before he missed the rest of the season with injuries.
Supposedly, he's healthy. Yes, he's overweight. Maybe he can get in better shape in the next few weeks. If he can even come close to the performances he put up in 2004, 2005 or 2007, he could be a serviceable fifth starter.
Am I expecting that? No, I'm not. But neither is it impossible. Maybe you think it is; if so, post a projection like that. The form is after the jump.