Book Review: "Willie Mays: The Life, The Legend"
Continuing today's book review series, I had heard about "Willie Mays: The Life, The Legend" before it was released so I wound up going out to buy a copy not long after it hit the bookstores.
Willie is 79 now -- he's just a few months younger than Cubs Hall of Famer Ernie Banks -- and for those of you who never saw him play (I did, a few times, near the end of his career), you may not realize just how great Willie was. Willie's statistical record doesn't even begin to tell the story, which is well laid out in this biography (the first "authorized" bio of Mays; he cooperated with the author and gave many interviews for it).
The 660 HR that Willie hit could have been more -- he spent two years in the Army after his Rookie of the Year season in 1951. It can be argued, since he hit 41 and 51 homers the two years after his return, that he might have hit somewhere around 80 in the two years he missed -- which would have had him, not Hank Aaron, as the first to surpass Babe Ruth.
Mays, writes James Hirsch, had that kind of rock star aura, the aura that Ruth had, in his early years. It didn't start out that way -- recalled in May 1951 after hitting .477/.524/.799 (yes, a 1.323 OPS, that's not a misprint) in 164 plate appearances for the Giants' top farm club at Minneapolis, Mays couldn't buy a hit for his first couple of weeks in the major leagues. Depressed and thinking he was a failure, guess who helped him? That's right, his manager, Leo Durocher -- who stuck with him and became a father figure to him.
The book details Mays' childhood in Alabama, a fairly typical one for a young black man growing up in the South in the 1930's and 1940's; how his great athletic ability got him noticed and signed by the Giants; and how he made it to the major leagues just after his 20th birthday.
You'll learn a lot about the racism of the times and how Mays tried to rise above it and just be himself. He was criticized by Jackie Robinson at the time for not "doing more" to promote the cause of civil rights, but Mays felt he was helping just by being who he was -- and in some ways, he was correct: Willie Mays was probably the first black professional athlete to be viewed as a superstar for his performance, not for just being a black superstar.
Willie was even affected by racism after the Giants moved to the supposedly "progressive" city of San Francisco in 1958; the book explains why and how.
And, the book talks about the love shown for Willie when he returned to New York, traded to the Mets in 1972 at age 41, long after his abilities had declined. In some ways, it's similar to what you see today with Ken Griffey Jr. in Seattle -- and Griffey is only 30 career HR short of the man whose uniform number he wore when he began his career (now, Griffey wears the #30 his father wore).
This book is not only the comprehensive story of a man who (in my opinion) is one of the five greatest players in the history of the game. It's also a chronicle of one of the most important eras not only in baseball history, but in American history.
19 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Willie
I first saw him in 1959, and I still say he’s the greatest I’ve ever seen. Hard to describe a player like him to the youngerset, who never saw him and only goes by stats. You nailed it, Al, he was much more than his stats, although had he played in a more homer friendly park than Candlestick (which before the park was upper decked all around, was a terrible place to play) he’d almost certainly would have had 700 – 750. I believe had he played in the 80’s when the stolen base was more in vogue, he could also have stolen around 75 per year. My greatest dream was “almost” realized when he played in the 1965 all-star game, and wore a Cub batting helmet. For that brief moment, I could pretend he played for my Cubs.
"It's a funny old world. Man's lucky if he gets out of it alive." W.C. Fields
There have been studies made of Mays and Candlestick Park.
It’s mentioned in the book. The only year he was really hurt by Candlestick was its first year, 1960, when he hit 12 HR there and 17 on the road. That year, Candlestick was completely open in the outfield and had longer fences. They made adjustments in 1961 and Mays hit 21 HR there in ’61, 19 on the road.
It’s not likely he lost more than 15-20 HR to Candlestick over the 12 years he had it as his home park.
"You can observe a lot just by watching." ~ Yogi Berra
I, too, was lucky enough to see him a couple times.
Mays was one of the very best ever. And a classy guy to boot.
I wonder how he’d fare today if he was playing age…
Saw him play in my first game at Wrigley Field in 1958.
He was one of the greatest, no doubt about it. Anyone remember his Coke commercial? He’d take a drink from a bottle and say something like, “Ahhh, that Coke tastes real great, man.” We would imitate him, out of respect, every time we drank a bottle of coke for years after that.
One of Lee Elia's 15%
Mays
I believe he is the only player I’ve ever seen score from first on a single with no errors.
Game 7 of 1973 World Series
Willie Mays did not play in it. Don Hahn was the starting centerfielder for the Mets and went 3 for 4. I do see that the Mets got the tying run up to the plate in the 9th inning. How amazing would it have been for Mays to have hit a game-tying pinch-hit home run in the 7th game of the World Series? Chances are that an extremely diminished Mays would not have come through, but I’m sure most people would have liked to have seen Mays have the opportunity.
"The big possums walk late." - Harry Caray
Conflicting feelings, saw him at Wrigley many times in late 60's
he always seemed arrogant to me as a Cub fan, not the warm friendly persona of our own Mr. Cub.
I distinctly remember sitting in the center field side of the LF bleachers, and having a blast serenading him (with a couple hundred others) with "Wiliie Mays, superstar, Who in the hell do you think you are", to the tune of J.C . Superstar, until he finally turned and sneered at us.
Now, I think of him as sort of sad story. He doesn’t seem to get the recognition he deserves, and is remembered more for a very late career demise rather than superstar he truly was. Can you imagine a Willie Mays in the game today? No one comes close.
"The Cubs are due in sixty-two." - #14
Growing up in the SF Bay Area
I got to see him play dozens of times, and he is the best ball player I have ever seen. There seemed to be nothing he could not do well.
As for home runs he lost playing at the Stick, I think some of you underestimate how many he lost playing there.
I always turn to the sports section first. The sports page records people's accomplishments; the front page has nothing but man's failures.
~Earl Warren
Best I ever saw, thopugh it was only on TV.
but I read a biography about him in the early 1960s that he had to have collaborated on. I remember reading in it about how lost and lonely he felt those first two weeks in the Majors when he wasn’t hitting, and how much Durocher’s faith in his abilities meant to him.
I also remember him talking about having amphetamines in his locker. I am going to have to look this stuff up now. :)
"I lof to hit de home ron!"
Okay
There were two that I read back in the sixties. One was The Willie Mays Story by Milton J. Shapiro, and the other was Willie Mays: My Life In and Out of Baseball, as told to Charles Einstein.
I bet they are going to be hard to find. but my point is that I am certain that Willie would have had to cooperate/collaborate on those two books.
"I lof to hit de home ron!"
Supposedly...
… the current bio is the first, and only, one that had Willie’s complete cooperation.
"You can observe a lot just by watching." ~ Yogi Berra
The Bob Costas interview was cool too, saw it in the offseason.
"Well-behaved women seldom make History"---Laurel Thatcher Ulrich
Mays vs. Cubs
Certain players, not usually superstars, developed into what I would call “Cub killers”—opposilng players who really managed to hurt the Cubs. It seems to me that Mays hurt the Cubs a lot, but it could be because he hurt everyone.
Any sense if Mays’s numbers against the Cubs were better than those of his against other teams?
"All I'm asking for is what I want." -- Ricky Henderson (on his contract dispute)
Mays hit...
.315/.387/.610 against the Cubs. The only team he had a higher OPS against was the Dodgers.
He also hit 54 lifetime HR in Wrigley Field. That’s the most by any visiting player. (BB-ref says 51, but that doesn’t include the 1951 season, which they don’t have in their game logs yet.)
"You can observe a lot just by watching." ~ Yogi Berra
Suspicion confirmed
No wonder, then, I think of Mays batting and Jack Brickhouse saying, "Look out, that’s hit… way back there… back… back… oh brother!
"All I'm asking for is what I want." -- Ricky Henderson
by sweetswinger on Apr 14, 2010 9:12 AM CDT up reply actions
I think
Banks deserves to be in the same list.
"I lof to hit de home ron!"
I just don't see Banks being at or even near the same level as Mays and Mantle.
Banks was a great hitter, but Mays and Mantle were much better all-around players.
I always turn to the sports section first. The sports page records people's accomplishments; the front page has nothing but man's failures.
~Earl Warren
by lookingdeadred on Apr 14, 2010 1:47 PM CDT up reply actions
Banks could have been.
Injuries prevented him from being at that level. Look at Ernie’s career up to 1961 — he was on that path.
"You can observe a lot just by watching." ~ Yogi Berra

by 





















