clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

A former Cubs No. 1 draft pick is attempting a comeback... at age 37

New, 174 comments

Remember the movie “The Rookie”? It might be happening again.

Luke Hagerty
MLB Photos via Getty Images

The 2002 film “The Rookie” was the story of Jim Morris, a pitcher who’d been the Brewers‘ first-round pick in 1983. After a few years in the minors his career ended due to injury and he became a high school teacher and baseball coach. One day Morris was throwing baseballs around with his team, showed good velocity and promised his players he’d go to a tryout if they won their district title. They did, and he got a tryout with the then Devil Rays, who signed him to a minor-league deal.

Morris pitched for Tampa Bay in 1999 and 2000, making 21 appearances and posting a 4.80 ERA, at age 35 and 36.

It was a great feel-good story and the movie, starring Dennis Quaid as Morris, was pretty good as well.

Now, this true story might be repeating itself. Luke Hagerty, a 6-7 lefthander, was the Cubs’ supplemental first-round pick in 2002 (32nd overall) out of Ball State. He pitched very well at Boise that summer, then blew out his elbow and had Tommy John surgery. Hagerty came back and pitched for the next few years in the minor leagues, and the results weren’t good. He was selected by the Orioles (who traded him to the Marlins) in the 2004 Rule 5 draft and later returned to the Cubs. He last pitched professionally for Schaumburg in the independent Northern League in 2008.

Hagerty now runs a facility called X2 Athletic Performance Training in Scottsdale, Arizona. Sunday, there were scouts watching some pitchers throw at Driveline in Seattle, including Hagerty:

You’ll notice a few other recognizable names there, former major leaguers Daniel Moskos, Joe Beimel and Tyler Matzek. (Beimel is even older than Hagerty; he’s 41.)

And in front of those scouts, Hagerty did this:

I mean... a lefthanded pitcher who can throw like that, why not sign him? I’m not the only one who feels that way:

According to this, the Cubs did watch this throwing session:

Here’s what Hagerty had to say on Twitter before the throwing session:

And, here’s some video of him throwing:

If you think the Cubs signing Hagerty would be crazy, I remind you that the Cubs recently signed 35-year-old Mike Zagurski to a minor-league deal and invited him to spring training. Hagerty is about two years older than Zagurski, but he’s lefthanded and if he can throw 95+, he can almost certainly get major-league lefthanded hitters out. Why not give him a minor-league deal with a NRI?

Hagerty pitching in the big leagues would be the coolest comeback story since “The Rookie.”